Skip to main content

The Obedience Jar

We're having a rough time with obedience in our house these days. I'm not sure if it's the new baby, or the endless hours trapped inside by snow and cold, or everyone hitting a developmental issue at the same time, or all of the above. Whatever the case, my two big boys and myself have all been a mess of frustration and yelling and overall grumpiness.

Isaac and I have talked once or twice in the past week about rewarding positive behavior, but I have to be honest: the thought of keeping track of their good decisions on top of their bad decisions seemed totally overwhelming to me. Never mind that my main goal in mothering these little sheep should be, well, the shepherding of their souls, following through on yet another thing seemed impossible.

But mothering is sort of about doing the impossible, you know? And after yesterday, something had to be done. So this morning, when Levi went to put his shoes on the first time I asked, without any whining or complaint, I took swift and decisive action. Enter: the obedience jar.


I grabbed an old applesauce jar, slapped a label on it (construction paper and packing tape, nothing fancy here), and approached him with the container of pompoms. 

"Thanks for obeying cheerfully the first time!" I told him. "Put a pompom in the jar. When the jar is full, we'll go out for ice cream!" (My husband may have blinked twice at this spontaneous promise. I didn't consult him first.) Then I showed the jar to Owen and explained it to him, too.

I realize this is only the first day, but the boys are ecstatic about the obedience jar. It hasn't been a completely stress-free day, and in fact I had to take one pompom away after a more deliberate infraction, but for the most part they've been considerably more compliant than yesterday. Owen came upstairs for nap time the first time I asked (a huge deal), so I told him we'd put a pompom in the jar after he woke up. His first words upon awakening? "I want to pick out a pink pompom." He hadn't forgotten.

I didn't come up with this on my own. I know I have at least two friends who have done or are doing similar things, probably more. I'm just passing along ideas here. Who needs a big reward chart when an old applesauce jar will do?!

Update: the very next day, we didn't put a single pompom in the jar. Rough, rough day. But I'm still hopeful that the motivation to make good choices will increase. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Vanilla and Snowflakes

You may remember from my Goin' Crunchy 2011 post that I started a batch of homemade vanilla back in May. It's all ready for use now, just in time for Christmas gifts!  I bought these little bottles  and a pack of winter-themed address labels on clearance at Target, dug through my craft boxes to find some old ribbon, and ended up with this: (You can't see it, but there is coordinating ribbon around the sugar jar, too.) As you can see, after I was done using my vanilla beans for extract, I cut them up into 2-inch pieces and covered them with white sugar in baby food jars: after about a week, the sugar is delightfully vanilla-flavored!  I haven't used it yet, but hear it's great for sprinkling on baked goods or oatmeal, or stirring into coffee or tea.  Packaged together in a little gift bag, they're making a nice small (and frugal!) gift for . . . those people who need nice, small, frugal gifts.  :)   In other news, I picked up a $1 sheet of snowfla...

Homeschool Curriculum 2025-2026

Given the ages of my children, I will only have two years when I am actively homeschooling all six kids, and this is the first. I have more spreadsheets going than ever before, four student paper planners, one kid using Google Classroom for assignments again, and a giant schedule on butcher paper so that everyone knows whose turn it is in the living room (for instrument practice) or on the laptop. BRING IT ON. Pretty sure we've only gotten all six kids awake for family devotions once in 8 days of school. LEVI: 11th grade Math: linear algebra and multivariable calculus through PSEO at University of Minnesota (online) History: AP world history at Sartell High School, second semester Science: AP physics C (one each semester) online English: World Literature: LLATL gold , Advancing Through Grammar Language: self-study German, with plans to take the AP German test next year Bible: Dust to Glory (Ligonier online) New Testament Extracurricular: piano first semester, wind ensemble at Sarte...

More Pom-pom activities

That dollar or so I spent on a bag of fuzzy pom-poms might have been the most useful dollar ever. Both boys continue to be entertained by pushing them through the lid of an old peanut container , an activity I pull out whenever there is an emotional crisis mounting. I've been collecting toilet paper rolls in hopes of doing this stick-counting activity , but I have yet to gather enough suitable twigs.  So I created my own conglomeration of several activities I've seen: Levi used small tongs to put the pom-poms in the tubes, counting to match the number on the tube.  He recognizes the number words one, two, three, and six, so I opted to leave the numbers off and let him figure out which tube "said" which number. Like my lazy masking-tape construction? :) I belatedly remembered that we've done a similar activity before to practice colors: I've got a set of toilet paper tubes with colored paper around them!  Not surprisingly -- that was six months ago -- ...